Astrology: Television: ‘Homeland’: Carrie’s and Brody’s Planetary Neuroses

Dec 18, 2012

Showtime

Falling in love has been described as each partner’s infatuation with the other’s neuroses. Nowhere is the adage more true than on “Homeland,” the Emmy award-winning drama from Showtime which just broadcast its Season 2 finale.

Although viewers became increasing disenchanted with implausible and irksome character behavior this season, to say that “Homeland” fell off the pedestal this season is unwarranted. Not if you appreciate how the show has managed to keep up the constant and dizzying interplay between two key archetypal energies of illusion and reality.

In Season 1, viewers became rabidly involved with the twisty psychological exploration and reveals related to returning war hero Nicholas Brody (Damian Lewis) and the mental state of CIA operative Carrie Mathison (Claire Danes).  Both Lewis and Danes deservedly snagged best-acting awards for performances that unselfconsciously revealed their characters’ underbellies. Each seamlessly wove in and out of Neptune: idealism, transcendence, instinct, seduction, lies and compassion. And right when you thought they couldn’t get farther from the earthly realm, Saturn – commitment, responsibility, organization, truth and practicality – leapt to the fore. The Carrie-and-Brody love story is nothing more than each of them becoming enamored of the other’s Neptunian and Saturnine archetypes.

Carrie’s Neptune is fixated on not letting another 9-11 catch her off guard. Her idealism is supported by instinct, yet firmly anchored in taking Saturnine charge. Her bi-polar disorder makes her instinctual proclivities even more vivid and urgent, and her rashness amidst her demands for executive measures makes her appear even more of a leader.

Brody does a similar dance. His Neptune expression involves having been seduced and brainwashed by his captor-turned-savior Abu Nazir (Navid Negahban). He’s suffered almost paralyzing sadness over the death of Nazir’s son which was brought about by the U.S. vice president that congressman Brody had served. And he methodically planned (Saturn) to seek vengeance through a terrorist act of his own. Having been captured by Carrie at the beginning of Season 2 – a play on his wartime captivity, described in the first season – Brody was forced this season to surrender to CIA rules, the terms of which were set in place by Carrie.

“Homeland” milked these archetypes for all they were worth in Season 2. In the finale, the illusory, Neptunian and not-of-this-world nature of their love collided head-on with Saturn business: Brody had to leave town fast to avoid yet another capture. Carrie’s Neptunian declaration to flee with him was a Saturnine ploy so that she could clear his name and not have to give up her profession (Saturn) that feeds her Saturnine desire to be respected and excel in the world, rather than just privately, as Brody’s lover. But far from being let down, with each character feeling they’re settling for second best, Brody trusts Carrie’s mission, and Carrie believes Brody.

An overlooked yet critical moment in the finale was Carrie’s nemesis David Estes’ (David Harewood) Saturnine-edged eulogy for the vice president, calling the deceased a man of conviction and principle. Truth is, just about every character on “Homeland” is a person of conviction and principle. It’s just that, more than in other television programs, Neptune gets in the way and makes the specifics of that “conviction” a debatable topic.

As long as these dual archetypes continue to eat Carrie and Brody alive, there’ll arguably be more palm-on-the-forehead moments from Saul Berenson’s (Mandy Patinkin). Now with Brody on the Carrie-abetted lam – the seemingly “reformed” terrorist and CIA-cooperative is the key suspect in the car-bombing of the CIA building that killed 200 people, including Estes – we’re heading into Season 3 with an ostensibly new al-Qaeda operative running the show. More Neptunian ideals, more Saturnine methods of implementation, and more improbable character behavior. More of the same? Count me in.

Astrology Television Rating: ♆♄ (Neptune, Saturn)

Facebook Twitter Email

Recent Posts

Archetypes: Film: Review: ‘Gone Girl’ (2022)

Containers abound in Gone Girl, directed by David Fincher and based on the popular novel by Gillian Flynn, who wrote the screenplay. There are envelopes, which hold the clues for the treasure hunt Amy Elliott Dunne (Rosamund Pike) has prepared for her husband Nick...

Archetypes: Film: Review: ‘The Giver’ (2014)

Many people refer to their homeland as the mother country. Those people didn’t know The Chief Elder, a matriarch as stern as they come who’s running the show in the country depicted in The Giver. Directed by Philip Noyce and based on the YA book by Lois Lowry, The...

Archetypes: Film: Review: ‘Get On Up’ (2014)

It’s all there. The riffs, the shoes that swivel maniacally as though greased, the slurrified words, the clipped throaty growls. But Tate Taylor’s Get On Up, the biopic of soul-funk innovator and icon James Brown, ups the ante by letting us see the legend living out...

Archetypes: Film: Review: ‘The Congress’ (2014)

Can the veil that separates Saturnine corporeal reality from the transcendent Neptunian realm actually be a cruel trick devised by Hollywood moguls? Yes, indeed, and it’s the premise of Ari Folman’s part live-action, part animated film The Congress, loosely based on...

Archetypes: Film: Review: ‘Calvary’ (2014)

Everyone has a cross to bear. But a parish priest tending his flock in Ireland’s County Sligo has really gotten more than his share in Calvary, a movie that addresses archetypal Pluto issues of power, abandonment and revenge, as well as Neptune themes of sacrifice and...

Archetypes: Film: Review: ‘Lucy’ (2014)

Luc Besson’s new sci-fi thriller Lucy could easily have been titled Mercury in Hyperdrive, a breathless tale about the archetype that rules thought and communication gone cinematically ballistic. Bigger, faster and stronger describe the new-and-improved mental...

Archetypes: Film: Review: ‘A Most Wanted Man’ (2014)

The grim espionage business relies, for its success, on Neptunian deception and Plutonic penetration of secrets. The most clever master spies throw a third archetype into the mix: the Saturnine User, who’ll exploit the captured by making them spy on their own people...

Archetypes: Film: Review: ‘Magic in the Moonlight’ (2014)

If art is the beautiful lie, can love also be ushered into existence by duplicity? That’s the question at the center of Magic in the Moonlight, a movie inspired by early 20th century Europe’s fascination with spiritualism, seances and communicating with the dead....

Archetypes: Film: Review: ‘I Origins’ (2014)

The old adage – that the eyes are the gateway to the soul – gets all scienced up in I Origins, a movie that asks whether Saturnine, data-driven science trumps knowledge that bypasses logic. Directed and written by Mike Cahill, the movie’s core question – Can reality...

Archetypes: Film: Review: ‘Dawn of the Planet of the Apes’ (2014)

In the annals of history, many liberators of the oppressed freed their citizenry only to become tyrants themselves. It’s this age old cycle of restrictive Saturn sidling up to revolutionary Uranus – a rhythm that topples and rebuilds civilizations – that’s at the core...

Archetypes: Film: Review: ‘Boyhood’ (2014)

For most of us, life is way too busy to allow for keen observations of minute gradations of growth and blossoming of family members, friends and other significant individuals who help grace our time on the planet. Perhaps it’s for this reason – our lack of attention...

Archetypes: Film: Review: ‘Tammy’ (2014)

Mention the word “Tammy” and “movies” in the same breath and, with any luck, the visuals that come to mind center on Debbie Reynolds’ vocal rendition of the song “Tammy,” put to exquisite use by Terence Davies in his The Long Day Closes (1992). Reynolds’ tune is that...

Astrology: Film: Review: ‘Happy Christmas’ (2014)

As an exploration of the gifts and curses of creative vision, nothing beats the short, snappy Happy Christmas. Written and directed by Joe Swanberg, the movie takes a hard look at what happens when archetypal Neptune – whose bailiwick is artistic inspiration, music,...

Astrology: Film: Review: ‘Venus in Fur’ (2014)

If you couldn’t get enough of Jack Baker’s (Jeff Bridges) cinematic jaw-drop in The Fabulous Baker Boys, as soon as seemingly tone-deaf loser and gum-snapping chanteuse Suzie Diamond (Michelle Pfeiffer) starts to soulfully warble her heart out and blow him away,...

Astrology: Film: Review: ‘How to Train Your Dragon 2’ (2014)

Is every critter, human or otherwise, trainable? And, because training elevates the game and aptitude of the instructed, does the core essence of tutored trainees remain the same? Those questions – as well as Saturnine boundary issues about whether to label entities...

Astrology: Film: Review: ‘The Rover’ (2014)

Set in a post-apocalyptic world in the Australian Outback, The Rover is a Saturnine story about two archetypal loners, each having suffered a huge personal loss that needs to be rectified in a land where procedural justice is a thing of the past. Written and directed...